Uncategorized – Musings

THE BUILDER-GENERAL: A NATION’S LAST, DIGITAL STAND

Once upon a time…

Pakistan stood at a fork in the road where its growing youth, restless digital entrepreneurs, and globally dispersed talent saw glimpses of a future more connected, more efficient, and more fair. But the systems around them were still drowning in paper trails, power outages, and policies built for another century.

Every day…

Citizens navigated endless bureaucracy for land titles. Freelancers fought global payment blockades. Schools’ taught yesterday’s tools while tomorrow’s jobs demanded quantum leaps. Ministries, despite goodwill, operated in silos each with its own digitization agenda but no unifying compass. Until now.

Then one day…

The Digital Nation Pakistan Act, 2025 passed. It wasn’t a whitepaper it was a legal startup charter. It created three things Pakistan never had before:

A Pakistan Digital Authority (PDA) with real teeth, not token budgets.

A National Digital Commission, chaired by the Prime Minister, making it everyone’s mandate.

A legally binding Digital Masterplan, forcing every ministry, province, and regulator to sync with one mission: make Pakistan digital-first.

Because of that…

We now have a law that goes beyond tech. It rewires the entire operating system of governance. It mandates:

A Data Exchange Layer (Sec 2(e)) so ministries stop hoarding data and start interoperating.

Federated identity systems, open APIs, and citizen-centric digital journeys (Sec 2(g)).

A Digital Nation Fund (Sec 13) that can generate revenue not just from grants, but from taxes on API calls, digital assets, and service layers.

The legal right for the Authority to override conflicting legacy laws (Sec 28) and the power to demand real-time collaboration from ministries and provinces (Sec 12).

But even great architecture doesn’t build the cathedral.

Pakistan’s Digital Nation Act, 2025 might just be its defining moment.

It’s not a whitepaper. It’s a legal product spec. A blueprint to rebuild the country’s governance stack with digital-first logic and not just with APIs and dashboards, but with something more powerful: You ask what? Read below…..

Model-Context Protocols (MCPs): AI-native infrastructure that allows systems to interact, understand, and learn in real time.

This is Pakistan’s chance to build a government that not only works but thinks.

THE BLUEPRINT IS HERE. SO WHO BUILDS IT?

The Digital Nation Act establishes:

A Pakistan Digital Authority (PDA) with real execution powers (Sec 6–8).

A National Digital Commission, chaired by the Prime Minister (Sec 3–5), enforcing alignment from provinces to regulators.

A binding, annually updated Digital Masterplan (Sec 11), defining the nation’s digital priorities across all sectors.

But policy is only the scaffolding. Now comes the build.

DPI: THE FOUNDATION FOR AN AI-NATIVE STATE

Digital Public Infrastructure (Sec 2(m)) is the backbone of a digital nation. It includes:

Digital identity

Data exchange systems

Secure digital payments

Open, interoperable cloud services

But DPI today must be more than wires and ledgers. It must be cognitively extensible, able to support intelligent agents, autonomous workflows, and citizen-facing LLMs.

This is where MCPs are essential. Planning digital infrastructure isn’t about building roads it’s about securing the corridor. Imagine you need to connect Karachi to Peshawar. A short-sighted approach builds a 2-lane highway on the cheapest available land. It works today, but when traffic triples, you’re trapped: factories and homes now flank both sides. Widening it means bulldozing communities at 100x the cost.

The builder’s way? Secure the 8-lane corridor now pour asphalt for only 2 lanes today. You pay marginally more upfront for land acquisition, but preserve shoulders for future expansion. When growth comes, you add lanes overnight no demolition, no delays. That corridor reservation is your plan against obsolescence.

Pakistan’s digital highway’s identity systems, data exchanges, payment rails demand this discipline. Build MVP (2 lanes) but engineer MCP (8-lane rights-of-way). Don’t let short-term savings create long-term traps. We have done this many times over with financial inclusion mandates and other short sighted initiatives, led by the very people who know nothing about it, bankers, or ex bankers whose own banks could not do it, but in retirement we hire them to do this for the nation. The irony should not be lost on us as we build PDA leadership.

WHY MCPs CHANGE THE GAME

For years, governments relied on APIs to connect databases and services. But Pakistan can leapfrog to MCPs frameworks that don’t just connect systems, but allow them to exchange structured context. Think of how we moved from land lines to cell phones and the dividends it continues to pay. Do it right, vs doing it twice.

That means:

Land registries that speak to identity systems intelligently.

Financial aid systems that adapt to user history.

Health services that tailor responses based on citizen interaction, not form fields.

MCPs are how AI-ready governments will operate. The Digital Nation Act enables this through its emphasis on secure, interoperable data layers (Sec 2(e)), national infrastructure, and governance standards.

WHO SHOULD LEAD THIS?

You don’t need a multilateral consultant. You need a wartime CEO. Not someone to prance in Islamabad and tell people what they are doing, ideally never be seen talking about the work but instead executing.

A founder-operator fluent in building digital products and public trust equally adept at managing complex systems and shaping narratives in real time. Someone who understands that national sovereignty today means owning not just infrastructure, but the story. This is a leader who has built in the age of digital distribution, where platforms move goods, capital, ideas, and sentiment at scale. Whether it’s logistics networks routing in milliseconds, SaaS systems standardizing workflows across borders, or media platforms reaching millions with a single push the pattern is the same: velocity, trust, and control. Pakistan’s digital future will require nothing less. These needs understanding the country and its assets to be the foundational layer in building a National Information Infrastructure. Understanding context is key, that doesn’t happen by being a conference attendee or a twitter panelist in a nation’s transformation journeys or those who have relied on consultants at scale.

Built under scarcity, not excess. Anyone with b$ funds can build, but can you build in scarcity and lead to abundance?

Understands how to make a university like NUST compete with IIT not on brand, but on output. Also not believe the rhetoric that. We have 10k CS grads a year, we have under a 100 that can compete regionally and 10 globally. Come with solutions to change this.

Fluent in crypto, governance, and education as national assets but humble enough to partner with and draw the counsel of the new crypto SAPM. Embed your Crypto Czar in the Oversight Committee (Sec 9). Their role? Negotiate as equals not supplicants

Code-literate, scar-hardened, and fast enough to deliver v1.0 not ask Mckinsey to build performative decks.

Can prompt LLMs like Tiger Woods used to play golf on his day off.

Operational stamina to execute 18-hour days, credibility to command respect from generals and Gen-Z coders. No more uncles with ill fitting jeans with white shoes and turtleneck tents, who cant walk 2 flights of stairs without crowds cheering them on. Have your fill of Nihari but to represent Pakistan we need some one who is committed to their health and the nations. We don’t need an ozempic level shortcut to our challenges, we need real commitment to build fit for use purpose outcomes.

This isn’t an advisory role. This is a Builder General job. Also, if you want to hire favorite’s and has been’s you are doing the act a dis service. Don’t hire for what you see but hire for someone who can do. Also note, if you pay peanuts, you will hire monkeys.

THE MASTERPLAN: 5 PILLARS FOR HYBRID REALITY- The Real Non Kinetic Force

National Information Infrastructure (NII):
- What: Federated data exchange layer (Sec 2(e)) + edge-computing nodes on military-secured critical sites (power grids, highways).
- Why: Avoids “cloud colonialism.” Data sovereignty meets low-latency rural access.
- Military synergy: Leverage strategic assets (fiber networks, secure facilities) as NII anchors positioned as “guardians of national digital sovereignty.”
Talent Factories:
- Transform NUST into Pakistan’s IIT 3.0: Not just curricula but mandate 50% faculty from industry (ex-FAANG, ex-Silicon Valley founders). Embed crypto/Web3 labs funded by blockchain taxes.
- Military linkage: Veterans with cyber ops experience → retrained as DPI architects.
30-60-90 Day War Plan
- Day 0–30: Build the Digital Spine
  - Connect energy + data layers using military-grade fiber networks (Sec 17).
  - Establish secure data exchange protocols via MCPs.
  - Identify five high-impact citizen interactions to convert into digital workflows.
  - Recruit technical leads from Pakistan’s tech diaspora and FAANG Alumni.
- Day 31–60: Deploy Foundational Digital Journeys
  - Launch 3 end-to-end, citizen-facing journeys (Sec 2(g)) using MCP logic:
  - Land ownership verification (identity + property context)
  - Telehealth scheduling + triage
  - SME e-loan approvals (FBR + bank integration +situationally aware)
  - Each of these should be context-aware, multilingual, and mobile-native.
- Day 61–90: Talent Infrastructure Mobilization
  - Redesign NUST as a National Digital Product Studio.
  - 50% of faculty from industry.
  - Build labs focused on AI, cryptography, public systems.
  - Retrain veterans in cybersecurity and signals into DPI engineers.
  - Begin bilateral co-builds with Stripe, OpenAI, and others only with shared IP and local hiring mandates.
DIPLOMACY BEYOND SALES OFFICES
- Pakistan must resist the temptation to become a passive consumer of foreign tech.Instead, it must become:
  - A co-trainer of models: e.g., OpenAI fine-tuning Urdu LLMs inside NUST with shared weights + sovereign data access. Any one hoarding public domain information digitally must make it public for national interest for Sovereign LLM Models. A lab for AI governance: embedding policy layers directly into MCPs, creating templates others can adopt.A developer of its own MCP stack: that other countries can adopt or license, transforming Pakistan into a DPI exporter.
The Digital Nation Act enables this (Sec 20). The only thing missing is intentional tech diplomacy not for deals, but for design partnerships. An ambassador at large but for Tech. Not an other TDAP or PSEB who invite other Pakistanis to sign MOUs but do not respond to emails from real constituents who want to build, scale and invest, we also do not need an other BOI for tech, we need a universal representative for Pakistans Tech Ecosystem. The current bodies and models have all failed, if you think otherwise, this will fail also even with the best intent in mind. Talk to the real stake holders not that spend government money on foreign trips to show Islamabad that the PMs 15-20bn$ Tech export target has legs, it doesn’t even have the body for those legs to walk on yet.
Abundance Engine:
- From “consultant dependency” to founder-led execution: Hire Authority leaders (Sec 7) from Pakistan’s own mix from any where on the planet.
- Why founders > policymakers: A digital native who scaled startups knows how to digitize FBR faster than a 30-year IMF veteran.

Designing for Sovereign Governance without having to explain ourselves

The Act allows for:

Assignment of secure infrastructure (Sec 17)

Inter-agency expertise transfers (Sec 18)

Requests for coordination from strategic actors (Sec 19)

Translation: Military-run infrastructure can power secure cloud. Signals veterans can code mission-critical systems. This doesn’t need a press release. Just results.

WHY PAKISTAN NEEDS A “BUILDER-GENERAL” TO LEAD THIS

This isn’t a job for a Geneva-trained policy expert or a Davos-panelist. It’s a mission that demands:

Someone who’s scaled products in high-constraint environments: B2C at scale, B2B SaaS, and enterprise integrations.

A person who understands education as infrastructure: not just transforming NUST, but turning it into an AI production stack.

A crypto-literate pragmatist: who knows how to tokenize, govern, and integrate digital assets into public systems securely and seek help where they aren’t an expert, this is a role in humility with candor not a know-it-all role.

A founder-operator scarred by failure, sharpened by scarcity, obsessed with shipping.

This isn’t about ‘relating to youth.’ It’s about harnessing two asymmetric assets: military’s strategic rigor + tech talent’s disruptive velocity. Fail to fuse them? Pakistan gets digitized by foreign platforms, not sovereign code.

This is not “reform.” It’s a rebuild

PAPER DOESN’T WRITE CODE

The Digital Nation Act is world-class.

But like all great product frameworks, it will only succeed if someone builds version 1.0 fast on real infrastructure, for real citizens, with measurable gains.

This isn’t about Estonia envy. It’s about Pakistan setting the global standard for what a digitally sovereign, AI-native nation can be.

THE 90-DAY PROVING GROUND: SOVEREIGNTY VS. SUBVERSION

The next 90 days will reveal whether Pakistan’s digital rebirth is led by its people or auctioned to outsiders. We’ve waited decades for this moment; about a week has passed since news surfaced about the government setting up a committee to hire PDA leadership. If the government cannot install a proven builder within 30 days, brace for a familiar tragedy: a ‘global search’ orchestrated by foreign consultants. They’ll draft RFPs with impossibly narrow criteria, run ‘competitive’ bids for 12 months, and ultimately embed their pre-chosen candidate a loyal agent of donor interests, not Pakistani ambition. They may have already done some of the work.

We’ve seen this script in resource-rich African states and fractured democracies.

This isn’t incompetence. It’s institutional capture. The delay itself is the weapon starving momentum until desperate governments outsource sovereignty. Pakistan’s Act is too visionary to be suffocated in committee rooms by those who’ve never shipped a product in load-shedding.

The Non-Negotiables:

Appoint the PDA Chairperson in 30 days (Sec 7) from Pakistan’s own global builder cohort not Geneva’s consultant aristocracy.

Reject ‘global talent searches’ that mask pre-baked appointments. Scarcity breeds ingenuity; abundance breeds dependency.

Let the Oversight Committee (Sec 9) audit appointments not donor-funded ‘advisors’ with conflicts of interest.

If we miss this window, we don’t get a second chance. We get a digital colony. Let us no longer negotiate our future with those who have no interest in its success.

Let’s not waste the last, best stand.

Pakistan Zindabad!

The Tragedy of TRG A Story of Vision, Decline and the Cost to Pakistan’s Tech Future

Looking at the current news, it is with a heavy heart that I reflect on what seems to be the unraveling of one of Pakistan’s most ambitious technology ventures, The Resource Group (TRG).

📈 5-Year High & Present Low

All-time high: PKR 186.49 on April 25, 2021

Current price: PKR 56.68 as of June 20, 2025 — a ~70% drop from the peak

As someone who joined early at SATMAP (now Afiniti), built the first engineering teams from scratch, and later helped scale TRG portfolio companies including DGS (which listed on the LSE:AIM) and played a role in the early incubation of the idea/experiment at DGS of what would become the $600M e-TeleQuote exit. This decline is more than professional disillusionment.

At its height, TRGs key asset Afiniti was a $6 billion (perhaps more) jewel in a constellation of companies, many of which were seeded, staffed, and scaled from Pakistan. With over 6,000 employees in the country and several thousand more across a dozen or more global operating entities, TRG was one of the few truly international firms built from the Global South, anchored in the discipline of private equity and powered by the ingenuity of local talent. It was, in many ways, the country’s most successful soft-power tech export.

And yet, today, that legacy is like witnessing a liquidation sale, not in a market crash, but in slow motion: through boardroom reshuffles, asset divestitures, and courtroom drama, based on the publicly reported news.

The ousting of TRG’s founder, while presented as a governance necessity, triggered a chain of events that seemingly appear strategically reckless, if not economically ruinous. Afiniti once its AI-first flagship when AI was still academic curiosity has been gutted. IBEX, a top-performing Nasdaq-listed BPO built under the TRG umbrella, has seen large insider divestitures. From the outside the confidence seems to be shaking, with it, the earliest Pakistani Tech Dream.

But perhaps most jarring is the treatment of the affiliate companie’s, Pakistani workforce, the very foundation on which this empire was built. Lenders-turned-owners have reportedly/allegedly reduced employee headcount from the ecosystem that enabled TRG’s meteoric rise. It feels less like strategic restructuring as (some units are now lender led) and more like a dispassionate carve-out, where neither history nor human cost seem to matter.

Between 2003 and its peak, an original PKR 10 share catalyzed a multi-billion-dollar enterprise. This growth wasn’t theoretical it manifested in USD-denominated salaries in Karachi and Lahore, upward mobility for thousands of middle-class professionals, and the creation of a deep, scalable talent pool in AI, BPO, and digital marketing. TRG was arguably the first Pakistani employer to internationalize talent at real volume and velocity.

I was fortunate to hire hundreds of engineers, marketers, analysts, and operators over two tours across two TRG entities. We built DGS from a handful of people to over 1,000 in Pakistan alone, pioneering PPC and lead-gen capabilities long before the regional market even knew what those acronyms meant. We dreamed in data. We scaled in grit. And most importantly, we delivered. It was not easy, it never is, but there was a pride in doing things never done before at scale.

Now, all of that is at risk not because of market forces, but due to strategic myopia and a loss of institutional memory. This was no startup flameout; it was a mature operation with demonstrated outcomes. Its dismantling is less a business cycle than a case study in how misaligned ambition and short-termism can dismantle even the most promising platforms. It truly is a Platform.

Let’s be clear: great founders build great companies. Hired guns/PE Firms, no matter how credentialed, seldom understand the alchemy of mission, culture, and endurance. What we are witnessing is a textbook failure of that understanding, economic operators acting with surgical disinterest in the very communities that created the value they now seek to extract. You could argue, I do not know the details and I most certainly don’t, but I can still reflect on what is visible in media.

And yet, all may not be lost. There remains an opportunity albeit shrinking to preserve what remains, reorient toward long-term value creation, and ensure that the dreams TRG made real for thousands are not extinguished.

To the shareholders, employees, alumni, and believers my heart is with you. We built something rare. Let’s hope it’s not the last chapter, but merely the end of a miswritten one. I have no horse in the race just some reflections based on the news in popular media and some time to reflect.

Disclaimer:
The views expressed in this post are my own, based on publicly available information and personal professional experiences. This commentary is not intended to defame, accuse, or harm any individual or entity, but rather to reflect on broader organizational outcomes and their socioeconomic impact. Readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and form independent conclusions. This post does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice.

TL;DR

The Lost Decade Revisited

The Spark: May 2012

A single call—disregarding the long-drawn-out prior conversations—changed everything. A founder friend(Jeff) from my TRG-Satmap days shared that the time had come to scale on an idea he was building out. Lead generation at scale. The second coming of the digital gold rush, that’s what it felt like when he described it to me.

The Model: Digital Gold Rush, Reimagined

Here’s how it worked:

People hunt for things online. “Cheap internet in Boston.” “Fastest fiber in Miami.” “AT&T triple-play bundles.” Keywords. Gritty little breadcrumbs.

Our job? Build licensed landing pages—digital kiosks—to connect those hungry searchers with the vendors feeding them. By getting paid ads to redirect to those landing pages.

Think of it like this:

The mall, 2012. Telco kiosks. Lines of antsy customers comparing prices, bundles, install dates. Back then, it cost providers $90–140 to bag one customer there.

Now flip it digital.

Buy keywords for $0.50 to $5. Send the lead to a provider for 40$ .If they bite? Ka−ching. A$20–$40 bounty. The provider saves $50 per sale. No mall hours. Intent driven sales, no cold calling all inbound leads with users ready to buy with intent. Just a 24/7 money machine. This is the first time I learnt what 24/7 conversion engines feel like and how you make money whilst sleeping. A revelation and an epiphany at the same time.

Simple? Sure. Obvious? Hell no.

The Visionaries: Madmen & Masterminds

Most people stare at gold and see dirt. Jeff? He saw veins. A madman with a pickaxe, backed by Zia—a serial visionary who’d build multiple B$ companies out of thin air (story for another day). When Zia bets, you listen. I had already experienced it firsthand when I went to work for him to build the global delivery arm for SATMAP (Now afiniti.com).

So I did.

Packed up in Abu Dhabi. Moved to Pakistan. Boots on the ground.

The Grind: Building in the Trenches

The grind? Brutal. Multi-party deals. Investor egos. TRG’s infrastructure was a double-edged sword—brand power on one side, legacy noise on the other, with its share of opportunists and assholes along with incredible souls. Jeff’s company, DGS, was the engine. My job? Make the gears turn. But the structure was different; I did not work for TRG this time around, instead I worked for a portfolio company, DGS. Tougher yet, balancing the Chairman’s view (Zia) with the Founder’s (Jeff). Staying honest to where the paycheck was coming whilst balancing loyalty to my mentor Zia.

It was not easy. Zia makes you work to levels you don’t think you can, but it brings the best out in you. Lots of learning, many disagreements. Some say he has a reality distortion field when he wants to get some thing done, I feel that is his super power, being ahead of the curve. Many breaking points along the way, days where it felt like this was an insane thing to do. But a masterclass in doing better if you are willing to go through with it.

Jeff was also going through a life-altering journey, many challenges but some one who figured it out in real time. You realize the best and worst of people when you work this closely. The good outweighed it all as it impacted so much positive change in Pakistan. Memory becomes selective over time, I tend to focus on the good vs the challenging. I am sure if the tables are turned I would have had similar short comings. Its just that I’m narrating the story this time around so I get to choose the parts I share.

Gold rushes aren’t about the gold. They’re about who’s willing to dig while everyone else naps. And we dug hard… Like really hard.

The Climb: From Green to Grit

Easy? If I lied and said it was, you’d smell the rot.

I’d left Pakistan as a teenager. My Pakistan specific resume? A single internship at Hubco and a small exit on a consulting business, before coming back with global experience. Zero deep scars from the trenches of building, scaling, or leading domestically at this scale. Now I was back—green, hungry, and staring down a mountain that had energetic young souls who wanted a stab at scaling their outcomes.

First lesson:

You don’t climb a mountain. You carve it.

The Talent Revolution

We needed talent. Not just bodies. Diamonds. The 1% who’d trade textbooks for paid search algorithms. Engineers. Botanists. Medical researchers—anyone who would pass the screening test I’d built. All retrained to hunt leads like wolves. I became a mad professor—teaching myself Google Ads in stolen hours, then recruiting chemists and coders to unlearn their past and weaponize their minds for the new game. It felt oddly satisfying to see people scale to new heights. In the initial days, I was present for the first 300+ interviews in person and met every candidate we hired from the recruitment cycle. It was insane, unscalable but it built the most fiercely loyal and aligned team I have ever worked with.

The Metrics:

From 0 to 30+ paid search assassins.

From borrowed desks to 400 then 600 souls across two cities, eventually hitting 1,000.

From scavenged TRG furniture to building offices and a culture that people refused to leave and go home.

The fuel? Hunger.

A 19-year-old A-level kid earning 500K PKR/month by earning conversion bounties.

Civil engineers tripling salaries—70K to 250K—by mastering lead gen.

Women, 27% of the workforce, rewriting rules in a system built to ignore them.

We didn’t just hire. We ignited.

The Team: Forged in Fire

Hassan Ahmed, our CTO—architect of the machine.

Salman Wajid, the delivery savage who turned chaos into cash.

Ambreen, the HR whisperer who found talent and made them stay.

Great teams aren’t built in boardrooms we had 100s others, far too many to name, you know who you are. (If you were part of the journey would love to hear you comments in the section below the post and how you are doing now.) They’re welded in the wild, trust by trust.

The Chaos & Cashflow

Brutal? Yes.

When was I got on the ground, there was no board. No SECP paperwork. No employee payroll bank account, heck nothing. I was one of the signatories to the SECP shareholding document in trust for TRG. Just inter-company assignments from the principal investor, TRG. Just raw hustle. We reverse-engineered TRG’s decade of lessons into weeks and months. Built offices, bandwidth, fire escapes—even battled Google’s poachers from their newly established offices in Singapore who salivated after our talent pipeline and domestic bureaucrats who’d surprise us at 2 AM for “inspections.” It was the wild wild west.

Cashflow? A vice grip.

Customers paid net-90, sometimes 120. Growth bled us dry. But Zia—always Zia—saw the endgame. “Go public. AIM Market. Now.” Just like that, we had a flurry of advisors and investment bankers between Karachi and Lahore. We were finishing offices, putting a local board together, getting the optics to match the growth. We were never about optics, but going public required some level of structural growing up, to match the fantastic positive growth. I remember painting our makeshift expansion office with call center personnel, 24 hours before our consultants arrived in Lahore.

The Storm Before the Calm

Karachi. Lahore. Hiring lines so thick we needed traffic cops to untangle the streets. Kids in faded resumes becoming kings. Call-center rookies out-earning their fathers and forefathers. A country’s lost generation finding hope in lead-gen paychecks.

Why Tell This Now?

Because 2012 & onwards wasn’t just a decade. It was a heartbeat. A flicker of belief that Pakistan could build. That talent, when unleashed, could lift a nation. That “brain drain” could become brain gain.

We didn’t just scale a business. We proved a truth:

Gold isn’t found. It’s made.

Journey & Impact

Launched/Conceived in 2008, DGS accelerated into a powerhouse by 2012-2015. On February 14, 2013, we achieved a landmark AIM IPO, raising $20.5 million and unlocking transformative value:

Market Momentum: Opening market cap of $73.9m with a 27.7% free float – a vote of confidence from investors.

Balanced Growth: Only 10.8% dilution to existing shareholders, preserving equity while fueling expansion.

Valuation Metrics: Trailing multiples of 3.3x revenue, 22.0x EBITDA, and 36.6x P/E – signaling strong future potential.

Beyond Numbers:

This wasn’t just a financial win. We rewrote futures:

Global Mobility: Relocated talent from Pakistan (PK) to the U.S. and beyond, creating opportunities for employees to thrive internationally.

Skill Revolution: Built Pakistan’s first paid search specialists & software engineers to build atop googles search algorithms and ignited a lead generation revolution, empowering a wave of entrepreneurs.

Entrepreneurial Ripple Effect: Alumni from Lahore, Karachi, and beyond launched dozens of startups – from Lisbon to Kentucky – mastering digital innovation. Many became investible ventures in new markets (non-competing, of course 😉).

Legacy:

1,000+ lives transformed directly and many MORE indirectly, skills upgraded, and a blueprint for scaling emerging-market talent globally. DGS proved that ambition, when paired with opportunity, turns local expertise into global impact.

TL;DR

A raw, unpolished journey of scaling Digital Globe Services (DGS) from a scrappy emerging business to an AIM-listed powerhouse. Fueled by lead-gen innovation, relentless hustle, and visionary bets by Zia , it transformed 1,000+ lives, sparked a digital skills revolution, and proved emerging-market talent can compete globally. No fairy tale—just blood, sweat, and an IPO. The question is who will do it again and how soon?

Interventions for the Next Decade
Pakistan’s next decade demands founders who see dirt and envision gold—again. To reignite the spark of 2012, three interventions are non-negotiable:

AI as the New Lead Gen: Pakistani tech companies must pivot from outsourcing to owning AI-native verticals—think hyperlocal healthcare diagnostics, climate-resilient agritech, or vernacular LLMs in addition to global ones. The playbook isn’t chasing trends but creating them. Founders must marry domain expertise with ruthless execution, building “24/7 conversion engines” for the AI era. What you have is access to large data sets. Use them.

Youth as Architects, Not Labor: The youth bulge is a sword—grip the blade wrong, and it cuts. Upskill relentlessly: partner with global AI guilds, launch micro-credentials in prompt engineering, and incentivize startups to train, not just hire. The 19-year-old earning 500PKR/month in 2012? Tomorrow’s version builds AI agents that out-earn Silicon Valley.

Founders Grit > Founder Genius: Success will favor those who thrive in ambiguity—founders fluent in Karachi’s chaos and Regional markets. Double down on hybrid models: remote teams solving global problems, but rooted in local insights. Zia’s “reality distortion field” wasn’t magic—it was seeing two steps ahead while others whined about load-shedding.

Let me leave you with this: Gold rushes don’t repeat, but the hunger to create them does. A decade ago, we carved veins out of keywords and call centers. Tomorrow’s treasure lies in code, data, and the audacity to believe a kid in Lahore can outbuild a Stanford grad. Pakistan’s tech future isn’t about catching up—it’s about leaping. But listen close: AI won’t save you. You save you. The same sweat that scaled DGS must now forge AI factories, the same loyalty that welded teams must now anchor ecosystems. The mountain hasn’t changed—only the tools. So pick up the pickaxe. Dig. And when bureaucrats knock at 2 AM or investors scoff at “emerging markets,” smile. You’ve been here before. Gold isn’t found. It’s made. Again.

The Looming AI Storm: How Pakistan’s Business & Political|BABAS|Leadership Must Evolve to Survive

Pakistan stands at a critical juncture in its economic development. With one of the largest youth populations in the world, the country possesses a significant demographic advantage. However, entrenched in outdated business practices, Pakistan’s industry and business leadership has largely failed to innovate and adapt. As the world rapidly embraces Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), Pakistan’s reliance on inexpensive labor is under threat. This article delves into the urgency of modernizing Pakistan’s business landscape, to avert a looming economic disaster.

The Current Business Landscape in Pakistan

Youth Population

Pakistan’s youth population, accounting for 64% of its total population, is a double-edged sword. The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) reports that Pakistan has one of the youngest populations globally, with a median age of around 23 years. This youth bulge represents a massive potential workforce that, if harnessed correctly, could drive economic growth. However, without adequate job opportunities, this demographic dividend could become a demographic disaster. If you are young and reading this, heres some advice for you and some words of cation. TL;DR No One Is Coming to Save You.

🌟 An updated message to the youth of 🇵🇰💚

🌍 In times of economic turmoil and uncertainty, feeling overwhelmed and constrained by local conditions is natural. But let's remember, the challenges we face also present opportunities to reshape our destinies. #Hope #Opportunity https://t.co/jzhtPGgly7
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) May 7, 2024

Economic Crisis

Pakistan’s economy is grappling with multiple crises. The GDP growth rate has stagnated, hovering around 2.4% in 2022, down from 5.8% in 2018. The inflation rate surged to 27% in April 2023, exacerbating the cost of living crisis for millions of Pakistanis who continue to loose hope in the situation and worse yet in life at large. The fiscal deficit has ballooned, and public debt has reached unsustainable levels, making economic stability precarious. We are battling massive losses on state owned enterprises with only talk of privatization, every passing day causes tax payer losses and no positive momentum. If you want to understand the underlying breakdown of data of how the SOEs(State Owned Enterprises) continue to malfunction and those at the helm who have no idea about what to do, read the following thread.

Of State enterprises & Our Lost Opportunity to Modernize, Grow & Scale.

At Independence, Pakistan inherited 12 SOEs. This number rose by a bit in the 1950s and 1960s as some development authorities and corporations (e.g., PIDC and WAPDA) were established.
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) August 23, 2022

IMF Loans and Debt

Pakistan’s reliance on external borrowing has placed it in a precarious position. The country’s external debt stood at approximately $131 billion as of 2023, with portions owed to the IMF. The IMF loans come with stringent conditions, often leading to austerity measures that can stifle economic growth and increase social unrest.

Unemployment and Job Market

The unemployment rate in Pakistan is a critical issue, particularly among the youth. According to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, the overall unemployment rate is 6.9%, with youth unemployment estimated to be significantly higher. This translates to millions of young people unable to find meaningful employment, leading to a potential rise in social instability. The highest overall unemployment rate (11.56pc) is prevalent among the age group of 20-24 years. (Data and Stats below)

A country for old men. We have a serious disincentive as a nation for young people because those who are in government/responsible for economic growth have not been young in the last 4/5 decades. This is not an ageist tweet, trust me. Tough to legislate outside of ur demographic.
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) November 20, 2020

Lack of Modernization and Corruption Across the board

Pakistan’s industrial and business sectors lag in modernization. The World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report 2022 ranked Pakistan 110th out of 141 countries, highlighting severe deficiencies in innovation capability and technological readiness. Corruption exacerbates these issues, with Pakistan ranked 140th out of 180 countries in Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index 2023. Bureaucratic inefficiencies and political corruption hinder economic progress and deter foreign investment.

Imagine this, in 1970 our trade unions/labour leaders wanted a ban on automation for 15 years. So till 1985 we would have had work place hostility against computers. Same time frame where our neighbors were defining national curricula for CS.

Fast forward to today:-> Boomers &… pic.twitter.com/7n4VCgP36O
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) March 28, 2024

Social Justice and Education

Social justice remains an elusive goal in Pakistan. The literacy rate is around 59%, with significant disparities between urban and rural areas. The quality of education is inconsistent, often failing to equip students with the skills needed in the modern economy. The Human Development Index (HDI) places Pakistan at 154th out of 189 countries, reflecting the country’s struggles with providing adequate health, education, and living standards.

Elite Capture

Elite capture refers to the phenomenon where a small, wealthy elite controls a disproportionate share of economic resources and political power. In Pakistan, this manifests through the dominance of family-owned conglomerates that stifle competition and innovation. These elites often engage in rent-seeking behaviors, using their influence to secure favorable policies and contracts, further entrenching economic inequality. We have been hit in the face every day for the last 7 decades with this phenomenon. You must understand this before you try to solve for it.

Every one Talks About Elite Capture in 🇵🇰 but most don't do any research to find out what it really means or where it started or how it impacts us daily

We are quick to blame

Lazy to action

Indifferent to learn from history

Heres a 🧵 an attempt with some facts & data points
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) April 13, 2023

Now lets Talk about AI and AGI + Where we are headed..

Artificial Intelligence (AI): AI refers to the simulation of human intelligence in machines that are programmed to think and learn like humans. These systems can perform tasks such as recognizing speech, making decisions, and translating languages, often with a level of efficiency and accuracy that surpasses human capabilities.

Artificial General Intelligence (AGI): AGI is a more advanced form of AI that possesses the ability to understand, learn, and apply knowledge across a wide range of tasks, mimicking human cognitive abilities. Unlike narrow AI, which is designed for specific tasks, AGI aims to perform any intellectual task that a human can, with the capacity for reasoning, problem-solving, and abstract thinking.

Last week, I had the opportunity to visit Singapore, and the experience was eye-opening. The progress I witnessed there starkly highlighted how far behind we are in comparison. Don’t get me wrong, I celebrate humanity’s advancements, but it painted a somber picture of our own future.

To provide some context, Google operates a global accelerator program, and I have been fortunate enough to serve as a mentor for several years. At its core, this program aims to support startups by providing access to Google’s cutting-edge technology without requiring equity. Startups are paired with top global talent in the form of mentors, helping them to innovate and grow.

During my visit, I was involved in Google’s AI:First Singapore Accelerator. This initiative, in partnership with the Singaporean government, was exclusively for Singapore-based companies. The level of support and resources available to these startups was impressive and highlighted the significant gap between Singapore’s proactive approach and our own.

Singapore’s government and business leadership have wholeheartedly embraced technology, driving a wave of innovation that positions them at the forefront of global progress. Their commitment to fostering a tech-savvy environment is evident in the robust support infrastructure for startups, the strategic partnerships with tech giants like Google, and the relentless pursuit of technological advancement.

In contrast, our own leadership and business sectors seem mired in outdated practices, resistant to change, and slow to adopt new technologies. This reluctance not only stifles innovation but also hinders our ability to compete on the global stage. Singapore’s forward-thinking approach serves as a stark reminder of the potential we are failing to unlock due to a lack of visionary leadership and a commitment to modernization.

The Reality of Pakistan’s Youth Population

Despite the government’s frequent proclamations about the benefits of having a young population, the harsh reality is that this youth is under-educated, under-skilled, and under-exposed. As AI continues to advance, these young minds are at risk of being dominated by intelligent systems that can perform their jobs more efficiently and at a lower cost.

Education and Skills Gap

The literacy rate in Pakistan is 59%, with substantial disparities between different regions and socioeconomic groups. Furthermore, the education system is not adequately preparing students for the demands of the modern workforce. According to the World Economic Forum, Pakistan ranks 125th out of 130 countries in the Global Human Capital Report, highlighting the severe skills gap.

Technological Advancements by OpenAI and Google

Recent advancements by companies like OpenAI and Google demonstrate the disruptive potential of AI. OpenAI’s latest autonomous agents are capable of performing complex tasks such as content creation, translation, and customer service. Google’s AI tools are transforming industries by providing advanced capabilities in data analysis, virtual assistance, and design.

These AI tools are set to clean the slate for low-cost destinations. For example, AI-driven virtual assistants can handle customer service interactions more efficiently than human workers. AI-powered design tools can create high-quality graphics and content without the need for a human designer. AI translators can provide instant, accurate translations across multiple languages. Call centers, traditionally a stronghold of low-cost labor, are increasingly being automated with AI systems that can handle inquiries and provide support around the clock. But first, to really understand what is going on, you must understand the Myth of the IT Sector that has been created by the powers be, for us to act on next steps and not build IT Towers and Buildings we must understand where the issues lie.

"Breaking the myth of a robust IT sector in Pakistan"🧵

The shortage of qualified people is going to continue to hinder our ability to scale unless we go a new route. AI?

The 15 large companies employ between 20-25K folks, we've reached a roadblock to 2x Or 5x our tech exports
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) April 11, 2023

Some Sobering thoughts on whats to come..

AI systems excel in data processing and analysis. In industries like finance, healthcare, and logistics, AI can perform tasks such as data entry, pattern recognition, and predictive analysis more efficiently than human workers. A PwC report estimates that AI could contribute up to $15.7 trillion to the global economy by 2030, but only for countries that effectively integrate these technologies.

The Urgency & Will to Change & Knowing What to Change….

Investing in Education and Training

To harness the potential of our young population, Pakistan must invest in education and vocational training. Emphasizing STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) education is crucial to prepare the workforce for AI-driven industries. According to the World Bank, improving educational outcomes could boost Pakistan’s GDP by up to 30% over the long term. But we might already be too late, we need to start of by having less ministers and more doers. We cant fix a problem we don’t understand. Start with vocational training and re training of unemployed and underemployed youth in the field of AI enabled tools, services etc. The Irony being that the former Federal Minister of Technology who could likely not even use a computer is now the Federal Minister of Education. You can not change your outcomes with these Mickey mouse tactics. Our current minister of Technology has not really been in office long enough but early indicators clearly point in the direction that they are not much different from the previous one or the many former ones who have had no idea what they were doing(based on progress or the lack lack thereof). Working to either build PR, enjoy foreign trips, or do photo ops. Net net the outcomes and promises seldom fulfilled. From trainings to budgets being squandered across the decades we have had these ministries.

The devil is in the details.Burning tax PKR to do a lunch event in Mar '23 when the scheme launched May'22. It ends in 3months.Also it's all offline & is short 2200 trainings.

Can the minsitry share use of 590m pkr proceeds & a list of beneficiaries https://t.co/0NlpHrT466 https://t.co/vLfqf1rEQS pic.twitter.com/HkJ7JQ3loD
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) March 22, 2023

Encouraging Entrepreneurship

Creating an environment that supports startups and small businesses can drive innovation and economic diversification. Government policies should provide incentives for young entrepreneurs, fostering a culture of creativity and risk-taking. The Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) reports that countries with high levels of entrepreneurial activity tend to have more robust economic growth. For all my opposition on doing away with ministers and ministries, what we do need and continue to optimize is to promote SMEs, we have near retarded and regionally focused organizations who allegedly work for SMEs, all they do is show up to kitty parties paid for by Karandaaz and Bill & Melinda Gates and many others (not trying to single out these guys) in Islamabad, have some tier three food at Serena and do PR events and go home. Oh lets not forget, tag each other across social media and talk about their hard life. The real dis incentive this nonsense causes is stop those who are really working hard when they see baseline and crappy ideas getting support and funding but no outcomes. We have to try harder.

A Ministry for all Seasons for SMEs & MSMEs 🧵

We have a minister and ministry for every thing and a SOE(state owned enterprise) for every thing else.

What we do not have is a ministry focused on the real entrepreneurs of this country.

Let's take a moment to talk solutions.
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) December 7, 2022

Modernizing Business Practices

Family-owned conglomerates must modernize their business practices. This includes investing in research and development, embracing digital transformation, and fostering a culture of continuous improvement. According to a Harvard Business Review study, companies that invest in digital transformation are 26% more profitable than their peers. Here is the kicker, when you got in reality and stasticaly speaking old men running the country, its businesses and enterprises, who insist on in person meetings and wasting your whole day about “things in their time” you know this is a one way ticket to no where, we have to bring change where change deserves a chance, a the very top. Folks who became rich by holding on to dad’s money, dad’s friends, concessions, contracts and subsidies, will not want to do any transformation, digital or moral. But we need to move in that direction for the growth and sustainability of our youth. This country can not afford to keep its youth at home and un employed with only TikTok as their best friend. The net effect of that is that the AI Algo on that social media will actually bring more dis content to the youth when they see the have and have nots across geographical divides, no level of social media monitoring and management will fix that discontent. You must realize that you cant compete with AI and Algos by filling forms and stopping accounts. You must know your adversary (*inquire within). The saiths must be mandated to attend some level of basic AI awareness bootcamp or chai, what ever gets them in the door to listen to the voice of reason.

Public-Private Partnerships

Collaboration between the government and private sector is essential to accelerate the adoption of AI technologies. Public-private partnerships can fund research, develop infrastructure, and create a supportive regulatory environment. Successful examples from other countries, like Singapore’s Smart Nation initiative, demonstrate the benefits of such collaborations.

What should the Government & Business be doing?

The rise of AI and AGI represents both a challenge and an opportunity for Pakistan. But if only managed in real time. The current business leadership must act decisively to modernize and embrace technological advancements. The political folks at the helm must do away with building IT Parks and inviting has beens to advise on building educational ecosystem and modern growth led industries. We have this backwards. We continue to invite people who have access to local political and business franchises vs bring the host of Pakistanis who live and work globally who are experts in the space. We do not need committees. We need to Kum the Teas if you get my drift and do more work. We need less announcements, more action. But at the very core we need working and reliable internet, or none of this talk of the youth, goes any where besides to shit. You can not have a thriving digital ecosystem offline. So who ever is responsible for advising the powers be, my 2 cents to you, is being pragmatic and defining the exam question you want to solve vs solving for your own success as advisors and torch bearers of equality. We can see past this, the youth understand this BS they have seen enough, help them help us all get out of our economic mess.

Failure to do so will not only erode the country’s competitive advantage but also leave a generation of young workers facing unemployment and economic uncertainty. By investing in education, fostering innovation, and modernizing business practices, Pakistan can navigate this technological revolution and emerge stronger and more resilient. But the expiry date on this is fast approaching. To understand why, you must understand the competition, does not eat, sleep, or take bio breaks. Don’t believe me, see below.

This is wild.

OpenAI just dropped ChatGPT-4o and it will completely change the AI assistant game.

10 wild examples:

1. Visual assistant in real-timepic.twitter.com/D3qWzHGzaD
— Min Choi (@minchoi) May 13, 2024

OpenAI tried to steal the thunder with GPT-4o.

But Google I/O 2024 answered.

10 wild reveals:

1. Google AI Assistant via AR/MR glasses Project Astra pic.twitter.com/9NfAtLaiZl
— Min Choi (@minchoi) May 15, 2024

Digital Bank(s)/Bank(ing)/Fin-techs & The People Who Lead The Charge In 🇵🇰

As a consumer who is marred by sub-par digital banking services, let alone delightful experiences. I always wonder(ed) who are the anonymous faces that gather on our behalf and come up with experiences in the digital realm? Also why are most, if not all of these experiences so shitty? And why has not one single bank/fin tech etc really done any thing significant in the space. I have tried very hard to like the apps, services, user experiences, digital journeys, but they are generally illogical, badly thought out, detached from good user experience design and then some.

Look every one has a right to build their APPs/Online services the way they want to but given that these ones specifically impact the way individuals and arguably SMEs do business, they are helping no one. I would argue that the reason SMEs really don’t scale in this country is because of the horrendous lack of focus by the Incumbent banks and really consumer-intellect heavy products, that are neither intuitive nor shelf-stable.

Why did I add SMEs to the bucket, because that is the real value unlock of any of these players and their organizations understood stuff besides receiving trophies and accolades from circle jerk clubs of peers and attending paid conferences to evangelize the 1996 level websites & services they continue to crank out. No hard feelings, if any one took an objective look they would tend to agree.

Let’s start by identifying who the players are first. It took Some time, but it had to be done. *If you’d like an interactive copy of the file, subscribe to my newsletter or engage with the post here/retweet the original post

Incumbent CDOs/Leaders

So looking at the incumbent banks and their Digital Chiefs/Custodians, I decided to look at their digital footprint and their digital engagement.

The exam question being:

“Can some one who is not really digitally first/native, them selves, (based on cursory information online) lead/develop/build/guide/manage, the best digital experiences for their banks audiences?”

You can be the judge of the answer to that question & if you agree or disagree that their designed experiences come up to par with your basic expectations. Some of it has to do with the culture of the banks, some of it has to do with the background and experiences of the people leading the charge.

This data cant be used as statistically accurate; as its part, fact, part opinion part conjecture, part wishful thinking part frustration with the shoddy services as an end user that I have to endure daily.

In the spirit of generalizations, barring a few of these folks at incumbents, most have been moving around between banks locally, some, arguably have foreign experience, some in relevant fields, whilst others not. The issue is, when banks locally continue to hire people who have been learning only from “vendors” & their so called “conferences” in Dubai, the collective sum of the output is in front of us.

Please recognize that person with the latest IPhone or the tightest jeans or turtle neck , pinstripe blazers or socksless shoes is not the only or ideal CDO candidate. Nor the ones who talk the loudest or make the most noise are those who are the most ruthless politically at the bank(s) either. Its these traditions that have continued to F**k the consumers and continued to challenge the central bank who really wants to support digital first services and products, but they get disappointed by their babus of digital at commercial banks. Interestingly the regulator has more gravitas with digital vs the incumbents. So really need to highlight their efforts and digital stewardship. Good on you SBP…You know who you are.

Show me one key player in this list and show me some thing of value, significance, they built in this role or their former roles working domestically or abroad that can be attributed to being a local, regional or a global success in the digital space? Most if not all follow the same mentality, how many people report to me? How many days will I take to respond back to vendor/client emails? How busy am I pretending to be this week?

These digital leaders cant be faulted alone for the way things are, they are just victims of their own roles and self perceived success. Some humble pie would go a long way.

The issue is, what new “doodad, thingamajigy” is the flavor of the month that some one forwarded the CEO of the Bank.. The way that journey works is; the Banks CEO or Sponsors rely on some thing called the “down ward shit-sandwich” which is essentially to reign in the stooges, they find some thing from an other market, send a Whatsapp forward to the person in charge, and then ask “do we have this” (DWHT). This is how most strategies come about at Banks. Pleasing upwards..

Fu** the customer essentially, what the F**k does the customer know they want… Let’s build what the CEO or the Saith is asking for. So can you really fault the employees?

Job security, brown nosing, one-upmanship , big titles with no execution gravitas, zero technical and infrastructure understanding, is what brings us to this. This is not an attack on the employees of the incumbents, but more of an empathetic stance, “I understand your plight bro(s)” Also missing in no small part, is the fact that not one BANK in PK has a Female CDO or Tech Leader. Please do point me in their direction if I missed some one.

Looking further down stream on why some ones digital foot print beyond LinkedIn namely on Twitter/X is a good representation of their digital credentials, I couldn’t possibly point you to a scientific reason.

No less if you aren’t even some one whose end users/product participants cant even tag online, are you really proud of what you are building or leading? Or are you hiding from the work behind layers of obfuscated handles, company accounts, call centers etc. Basically if the buck doesn’t stop with you on digital journeys, where does it really stop? So you want the title, recognition, awards, salaries but not the responsibility? Again more a systemic issue than a role/person based one.

There are serious exceptions to the rule, none that I’ve seen at the incumbents but many at the upcoming fintechs/new banking product leaders etc. We will get into that list shortly.

So coming back to Twitter or even LinkedIn perhaps, the only thing most of these executives are experts in doing, from a community engagement perspective is taking stylized images of their business class flights, expensive wrist watches and the occasional “How do we fix IT exports” type debates. Clearly focusing on the wrong KPIs.

There is zero building in public, zero public apologies, zero feedback, just hyperbole and bullshit posts/copied from other places and most recently completely mindless ChatGPT output. Yes I’ve spent some time reading their posts last weekend. The most interesting ones are those where they write posts on GenZ and Millennial POVs, and you have 50-60yr old bankers & internal employees commenting on their posts, “great boss”. Talk about the Irony…

If you were a large share holder of these banks, a board member, a saith, a sponsor, or even the CEO, you should be asking: “How qualified are these people really to lead the single most important factor in your future growth as the challenger banks and fintechs come to town?”

You are about to be toast if either your banks goals aren’t aligned with your digital leaders skill set or you do not empower them, all the faults don’t lie with them, they are the output of a highly politically astute chess match that typically got them to where they are. But human instinct is survivalist at best and these guys have perfected it.

Digging further down, since we are being honest, some of these guys have re-branded their failed mis-adventures in to juicer titles/roles in their new companies and roles. My favorite example from some years ago is that every one in every bank who ever worked at EasyPaisa was “founder team member” of easy paisa or head of payments or “chief some thing”, I identified 7 of them at various banks using LinkedIn. Not my data or analysis just what their titles state. Gross inflation of designations leading to sub-par journeys for customers and no real traction in the digital realm. Forget financial inclusion, these folks cant even have a cohesive online conversation on the functions they are allegedly leading.

So far we have identified 5 Core issues

Lack of Digital Channel Engagement on part of the CDOs/Leaders
Title Inflation & Celebrating Fake Former Milestones
Pleasing Upwards
Being first for all the wrong reasons & products
Limited Exposure (domestic market job cycling) or horizontal movement from the region

We move along to the challengers next and their CDOs/Leadership.

New-co Banks/Fintech Digital Leaders

There is some traction in this space(Thankfully). Whilst these were the only folks who showed up on minimalistic LinkedIn searches, before you come at me, that there are many more fintechs and many more new licensees. Trust me I am not getting paid to dig out the folks here but genuinely interested in comparisons. With Sadapay and Zindigi we have seen the leaders engage heavily with the community online tackling questions answers, complaints. both Omer + Noman take to public engagement and hence I am aware of their community first approaches because it’s online. With Hugo, Atyab is seen as trying to build in public so thats a +1 for some one entering the market and clearly a lost opportunity for incumbent digital leaders who have insane brand recognition and distribution. So Kudos to these folks for trying as new-cos and new brands. But time will determine how successful they end up being, from the looks of it, they are trying a different approach and being mindful of their audiences.

The Easy Fix:

Bring in teams with digital transformation, expertise hire from adjacent industries
Build real talent on your boards with folks who have multi vertical digital experiences
Shed the sahabs/babus/relatives of the sponsors or their touts in positions that can change the fate of the banks Vis-à-Vis the real potential of real digital rails
Stop hiring McKinsey
CEO of banks need to really really really hire digital advisors or board members not just internal committee members. CEOs understanding of digital is really superficial barring 2-3 banks. Sorry guys, you may not agree but it’s the truth.
CEOs of Banks Need to Focus on SME/SME solutions think growth $s
Be very careful, that your brightest talent is going to be, and is already being hired by regional players. If you do not promote the right talent from within they will leave because they are sick and tired of working for your non-digital, digital leadership
For the CEO/Boards/CDOs, please start using your own apps vs relying on your CDOs for feedback
Take action vs making claims(CEO/Digital Leaders)
KPIs are your friends, not fake awards

What is really missing?

I continue to feel that the intent to build truly digital solutions is missing. Apps, websites, hardware, etc do not replace intent. Since 2007, I believe, when branchless banking regime came about, has any one really put out a comprehensive digital banking product, experience? Bi-weekly the industry continues to do MOUs, drive FOMO at their leadership cadres and the most successful digital pundits continue to get outsized internal funding allocations. Till there is intent nothing will change. With this, I wish the new-comers to really make a difference and lead with intent & for the incumbents to try one last time.

Net, net stop talking about digital and start innovating and putting in the right talent, leadership and KPIs with a view that most of your future customers are going be in their 20s & 30s and they are brand agnostic, only service will determine the success across your digital platforms and dreams so lead with intent or these new audience will move along.

This is a consumer driven view, I feel every time I write an opinion piece some one comes out of the woodworks and threatens legal action. Consider this a free audit instead. Focus on using litigation dollars for bringing about change instead. Consider this a public service for our collective growth. No CDOS were harmed during field research.

The ‘real cost’ of the 2+ Part Canadian Dream & Everything in between.

Canada is a fantastic place. It has great public infrastructure, friendly people, amazing natural beauty, and a wide variety of cultures and traditions. It’s a safe country where you can live a peaceful life if you follow the rules. But Canada is not immune to the economic pressures that the world is facing. Food inflation is above average, and the real estate market is completely unhinged. Rental prices are high, interest rates are high, and there is a shortage of housing.

As migration trends increase, the supply of resources like housing is being stretched to its limits in major cities. Public infrastructure is also being taxed.

If you are thinking about moving to Canada, you need to be aware of these challenges. You need to do your research and make sure that you are prepared for the practical realities of Canadian life. But don’t let these challenges discourage you. Canada is still a great place to live. It’s a country with a lot to offer, and it’s worth making the effort to overcome the challenges.

This is not an economic break down or a political one. This is a reality check for those who need to understand the facts and need to get their house in order before they embrace the Canadian life.

Because the minute they land they will face some thing called :

“The Canadian Experience”

“Canadian experience” for job seekers refers to the experience gained by working in Canada, specifically within the Canadian job market and professional environment. Many employers in Canada often mention “Canadian experience” as a requirement or preference when hiring new employees, especially for certain roles and industries. But a lot of folks are compelled to ask, after 20 yrs of global experience, how hard really is to do the same thing in Canada?? But let me clarify:

Having Canadian experience demonstrates that a job seeker is familiar with the Canadian workplace culture, norms, communication styles, and industry practices. Ive worked in over a dozen countries, trust me, Canada has its own pace, norms, quirks and assimilation criteria.

In part, just my observation alone, it is a small economy thing. With 38M people and being the 38th most populous country, it is not as Large as the US, (some thing most immigrants confuse it with), it’s also neither as ambitious as America as a homogenous population group (if i can take the liberty of saying as much) nor is it in any race to create millionaires and billionaires. Don’t get me wrong it will give you every opportunity if you want it so.

The drive in Canada for most Canadians from a work perspective is to “break even” on the effort and reward. It took me years of living there to understand this. It is not a bad thing, it makes the people happy, it drives them to doing other things in life. Their measure of growth, success and happiness is not related to work place success, some thing that at least I feel in over a decade spent in the US, as being part of most peoples identity. Not the same in Canada by a long shot.

It’s not just about the technical skills and qualifications, but also about understanding how things work within the Canadian context. This can include understanding workplace etiquette, customer service expectations, teamwork dynamics, and more.

For newcomers to Canada, this can sometimes present a challenge. They might have relevant skills and experience from their home country or other places, but employers may still prefer candidates with Canadian experience. This can create a catch-22 situation where newcomers struggle to get their first job in Canada due to the lack of local experience. The expectation of most employers due to immigration programs etc, is the fact that most people coming are either low(er) skilled, or without relevant (contextual experience) or both. This really skews opportunities for those who do not fall in that category.

Part 1.

If you are highly skilled and under 40 you have a fighting chance to make a good living which would entail that your skills translate directly, that there is no major waiting period to find work or re-certifications or the “Canadian Experience” ** requirement. That you can start plugging away to a 100 to 150k CAD$ role in sub 3 months from when you arrive or can actually start work remotely.

In my experience this can happen in a host of professions but typically Ive seen it happen for (Not a comprehensive or exhaustive list or perhaps even accurate)

Digital Transformation & Strategy Consultants who have global experience as part of say a big four role in their home country
Software developers with command over the english language and a Github repository and equal parts community advocacy that is searchable online
Specialists in Mining, Oil Production, Chemical Engineers and wait for it…..
Folks who have extensive freight, logistics, 3PL Chinese shipping lane experience
Lucky few who work for Global Companies and can do an internal role search and swap out to Canada
Free lancers who are solopreneurs who already make 5 to 10k USD a month who do not need local employment but can now access domestic payments, credit etc infrastructure to grow their own business and or add remote workers whose front end they become
Specialist consultants who have direct experience in Energy + Distribution business, folks who have industrial and mechanical experience in large public infrastructure roles on standardized plant equipment etc.
Automotive engineers who have hands on manufacturing experience with globally recognized certifications and work experience at a Toyota, Honda, BMW etc.
Entrepreneurs who use Canada as a new base of operations to target the US as an export market if their products and services allow
Influencers who can work from any where (never thought this would be some thing, but its real, I know a few influencers who have moved across and continue to produce content for completely different markets but use the Canadian backdrop and access to professional studios etc to 2X their business)
Digital Marketing specialists ala — Paid Search + SEO + SEM + Influencer Marketing, b2b, DTC + agency background is a god send especially if you have relevant platform level certifications and a demonstrable portfolio where you have been directly responsible for hands on execution and growth.
Cyber security specialists with modern tools + hands on experience
Industry specific Client relationship specialists (like hazardous waste handling or nuclear medicine etc).
Low code, no code specialists with demonstrable automation projects + platform certifications
AI, ML + Data science folks with demonstrable application of their work, models or outcomes.

Part 2

You are in the low income category without any directly relevant skills today and can take full advantage of government benefits or can stay happy even if you don’t earn a lot.

This is both a mind set and a reality. I am not listing this to expose some scam you can run to take advantage of Canada. On the contrary, this is for those, who feel that they are able bodied, they are willing to go the extra % and in any shape or form take their god given ability to do any thing, to get out of their present circumstances.

Canada will welcome you so long as you are willing to work hard. Canada continues to need folks with emerging skills, but recognizes that they may not pay enough beyond a working wage. That is off set by the government programs, access to public services and infrastructure. A roof over your head, and typically having the safety and security you did not have access to where you migrated from.

The world is a tough place, people have varying degree of circumstances so there are always going to be folks who are just starting off. If you find your self in that category, you are definitely going to be in a better shape in Canada. But you must understand the reality of that. It is going be hard, it is going to be no savings, not much entertainment but it will lead to you building the life you want, need, deserve and work towards.

The government will give you a hand for sure, but you need to come prepared that it is going to be a tough, taxing, mental and physical ride. There will be dozens of assimilation challenges, work challenges, lots of good bad and ugly people, lots of sleepless nights, lots of lost opportunities, lots of missed memories with loved ones, but if you have a goal in sight, you have the ability to do well for your self. Nothing will come to you, you will have to identify, enlist and avail the government support made available whilst working towards the goals you have setup for your self,

At every step of the way, what you will discover is the beauty of Canada, be it access to fair education, certifications, placements, subsidized programs, access to government backed loans for business etc. But this is a privilege not a right, use it wisely.

& Everything in between

If you have say, 20+ yrs of experience, or are in your late 40s , or mid-career or in a profession that needs; re-certification, local accreditation, additional degrees, very specific Canadian experience, licensing from trade bodies, associations, consumer groups etc. Let me be honest, you are perhaps in the toughest spot from a work perspective in Canada. Your initial time will be hard, it will go slow, the Canadian winters will make it harder. There is no other way to cut it.

Not because you cant achieve those but because the time value of money needed to go through this journey would typically mean that unless you are a 2 income household, where one income at least falls in Part 1 , only then will you have the ability, stability and mental wherewithal left to pursue the things you need/require to become a contributing member of society from a financial earn out perspective. Not to say that is the only way this can come about, it just gets easier if that is the case.

Heres my list of professions, professionals and trades that really need to understand and research what it takes to re-certify, re-apply and be recognized locally to be able to pursue their professional careers because it will take from months to years to be able to do this at a level that most established folks would like to see them selves at:

Teacher
Social worker
Therapist
Doctor
Clinical Researcher
Pharmacist
Dentist
Radiologist
Professor
Electrician
Plumber
Car Mechanic
Veterinarian
Accountant
Lawyer
Tradespeople
Building & Construction specialist
Private Investigator
Financial Advisor
Wealth Manager
Food Technician
Lab Technician
Law Enforcement
Human Resource Professional
Traditional Marketer
Supply Chain Professional
Shipping + Logistics Professional
Truck Driver
Chefs
Barbers
Risk Management Professional

+ Real Costs

Beyond finding work, finding sustainable housing and being aware of the many costs, that most of us/some of us may not be accustomed to is a key thing to figure out upfront. Whilst this may not be a scientific post, its definitely a realistic post from the point of view of the reality of what to expect as some one who has seen both ends of the spectrum.

Happy candidates for migration, (typically) become un happy migrants because the reality distortion field at the time of their acceptance to relocate was so high, their (relocation) objectivity suffered.

This is my plea to all those considering availing any migratory process to dig deep; deeper than hearsay, friends, associates, friends of friends, neighbors and least of all touts/ ala immigration consultants that have never lived in Canada or are not Canadian citizens nor are their firms operating from there.

Most people only see the YouTube accounts from people who are pushing to get views vs helping people out, whilst others are too deep and entrenched that they provide little to no value to a new comer who does not have an objective over view to benchmark against.

Heres a beginners guide to Real Costs as shared by my good friend Aizaz.

This is neither scientific nor arbitrary, it’s some where in between based on experience and prevailing market dynamics for the Extended GTA Suburbia.

The prospect of a better life gets better with planning and with the least amount of surprises. If you do your home work, if you understand what it takes, the likely hood that your outcomes will be far better than those who went without a plan is higher. Much higher.

The declining state of play in many countries and regions is definitely fueling migration globally. Migration may not be for every one, but for those who have decided that this is a step they must take and are about to go across, I hope these are things they consider carefully as they kick off what will perhaps be the biggest transition and commitment they have made in their life.

The parting advice I have is 3 fold:

Be willing to start at the bottom. If you don’t have Canadian experience, you may have to start at a lower-level job than you would in your home country. Be mentally ready for this, if you are not, it will not be pleasant.

Don’t be afraid to ask for help. There are many resources available to help immigrants find jobs in Canada. Don’t be afraid to reach out for help if you need it as there are dozens of government programs, services and aids available. If you do not ask you will not receive.

Bring a transferable skill that allows you to build an export oriented business. Imagine if you were in the business of processed food before you migrated. Now think about all the raw ingredients that went into making your product. Evaluate how many of them were Canadian origin. Since you already know the business it becomes much easier for you to source those products in Canada and export to similar businesses globally.

If you want to enhance your outcomes and move towards those in the list shared in Part 1: Subscribe to and read my weekly news letter on personal transformation and entrepreneurship at https://faster.beehiiv.com/

The Ambition Tax: How Corporate Culture in Pakistan is Robbing Graduates of their Professional Growth

The country is facing a number of economic challenges, including high inflation, a large trade deficit, and a growing fiscal deficit. This has led to a challenging business environment, with high levels of uncertainty and volatility.

In such an environment, it is important for businesses to attract and retain talented employees, who can drive growth and innovation. However, the high levels of employer dissatisfaction among the potentially qualified, young professionals make this difficult. As employees are more likely to leave their jobs in search of more challenging and rewarding opportunities for slightly more money.

This creates a vicious cycle, where high levels of turnover reduce the productivity of businesses and limit their ability to drive economic growth. Also not serving the GDP in any significant way, as they are part of a rotational pool of marginally skilled and sub-optimal resources.

Valued only, between players of a closed economy. Meaning that most of their value is not globally competitive and typically doesn’t stem from innovation or growth related skills. It comes from”beating the system” longest.

At the crux of this issue lies the much larger issue of corporations based in Pakistan. Be it local or foreign. The DNA over time for both, is nearly indistinguishable from the perspective of the Ambition Tax placed on the young graduates who join them with hopes and dreams.

So what is this Ambition Tax?

In my mind, ambition tax refers to the idea that the corporate culture in Pakistan is stifling the professional growth of graduates by limiting opportunities for advancement and hindering their ability to fulfill their career aspirations because at their core; these corporations are thinly veiled monopolies or oligopolies protected by subsidies, generational wealth, influence, political leverage and national security related items. Essentially any where else in the world they would not be able to compete. Let alone get to the scale at which they operate in Pakistan.

This is due to a number of factors, including a lack of transparency, stagnant growth, and seemingly large corporatized businesses being run like family-owned businesses vs globally competitive ones. Or large foreign owned businesses run at the whim & fancy of their local leadership who typically are in entrenched roles for decades on average. They serve the $ earning potential of their principals/foreign masters, by dealing with the dirty work in Pakistan and only reporting back on the growth.

These parties are almost also over in the Telco space and some Foreign FMCGs where billions spent to build brands, built many millionaires, setting the wrong work culture and success benchmark of colluding with advertising agencies and television networks to harvest hordes of cash. (Every one f**ing knows this, they just don’t have the courage to call out the insane level of corruption and lack of morality at these organizations)

Under the don’t ask don’t tell principle, what happens at Large Telcos/FMCGs and others in PK is glossed over by printing and sticking FCPA (Foreign Corrupt Practices Act)Rules by American companies and Value statements by most others.

In a crazy development, the local corporate groups have stopped pretending; they now consider their growth ambition linked to breaking the law and consider the speed monies paid as a natural symbiotic relationship between what they do and what the government has to do.

Like kids watching their parents and learning their traits, young graduates watching their employers, their companies, their peers, their bosses all being involved in 5 activities at large

1)Look Away

2)Control the flow of info to retain your job

3)Please the bosses/society by resigning to your fate (much like this kid who who got mugged)

This is exactly how the nation feels right now as the country has been hijacked by criminals. Totally helpless! pic.twitter.com/oLpN8thtDw
— Adeel Habib (@Adeel786) January 1, 2023

4)Play Politics

5)Do what you are told vs doing any thing extra

In a society that over indexes on “juggar” and under indexes on “ingenuity” and doesn’t know the difference, the only war we are at, is a war with our broken selves as one guy tries to pull the other down, in an attempt to take a piece of the available pie, vs growing the pie.

So whats going on? (At Large Companies)

One of the major reasons for the ambition tax in Pakistani corporations is the lack of transparency in the hiring and promotion processes. Often, positions are filled through nepotism or connections rather than merit and practice of not letting the old guard retire, look at the PSX 100.

You would be hard pressed to find directors in their 30s and 40s who are not family members of the listing sponsors, leading to a dearth of opportunities for young, talented professionals.

Major banks like HBL and others recently announcing they will retain their above 60 staff? The jokes write them selves, it’s a self rewarding club of boomers. They have to be retained because their counter parts operate in the government and its not worth the hassle to train a younger person on how to evade the system.

This creates a vicious cycle where the most competent and qualified individuals are overlooked, and the least capable are given positions of power, hindering the growth and progress of the company as a whole. The few who are capable and make it to some where, spend their time politicking vs focused on professional growth.

Cant blame them either, they went from, “I wish I had a job, to I have a great job, with most creature comforts, I better not f**k this up” when they hit this level, they are married to the roles job security, its monthly check, their nice offices a settled family life and a family co-dependent on their work outcomes.

In such a setting, the ambition is over, it is traded for longevity by subservience to those in charge. Large Pakistani corporations are where hope goes to die.

Banks how could I forget banks….oh Pakistani banks …

When I have taken it upon my self to put out the going ons at most if not all telcos and FMCG companies, Banks along with saiths, also deserve our attention. They are the epitome of ambition killers.

Let’s look at a young grad who gets into an operations role at 35k PKR. The Banks CEOs driver by then has a better total comp package including fuel, meals, and interest free loans. The driver is un skilled but the young grad is skilled. It would take 5 career jumps over 10 years to bring this person who enters the Bank at 35k to make a salary of 250k if they are lucky and suck up the right way and tolerate inhumane treatment from the public at large and their “seniors”.

By this time they are in their forties, have a family, and the charm to stick around, is the servitude the bank buys by offering a house loan. Lock stock and barrel, this 40 year old who looks like he’s 60, traded his caged existence for a loan because the state has no f**ing system to enable this. The banks, the saiths, the Sindh club biradri wins every single time. At the cost of the ambition the youth are trading for basic survivability and life events.

The CEOs wear tailored suits, typically enjoy a good bottle of single malt, I can name a dozen or more such gentlemen but thats not why we are here. Who by no professional conviction have gotten where they are.

They too are security men, who love their jobs and the security it provides to sit in well guarded homes, with their friends over single malt and build the courage to curse the politicians, their very own Sindh club peers, whom they lend to and wash away their sorrows into the night by complaining about the same. Do you not see the hypocrisy?

Most of these bankers/ceos/leaders, their numbers 2s and 3s are has beens, they wouldn’t be able to find globally competitive roles for the shit they deliver to the masses daily in PK. The only reason banks worked in PK is not because they are innovative, but because the government is stupid, and the awaam is land locked from access to debt and loans.

All these details not because Banks and Bankers have issues or me with them, it’s to paint the sorry picture of what is happening at the top and how worlds apart, the growth trajectory is for the young chap who joined the branch. To ever making it to the single malt club(if they so desired, not endorsing they should). They watch from a distance and their lips run dry in the delivery of the word “sir”.

Each Business unit head, each Management Team member runs a fiefdom in these corporations. Their fiefdoms are a microcosm of Pakistani society, where the most marginalized is the most subservient, but since he gets a pay check at the end of each month, he’s conditioned to make the most of the misery of being a personal slave to the business leaders. What do you think this daily torture does to ones ambition? It dies a slow but certain death.

Saiths, their children & the “principal, sponsor” drama….

Next we have the established saiths, their families, with alleged “professional” CEOs. Running large diversified but subsidized businesses because of concessions, cheap real estate, rebates, tax evasion or other such premium deals.

Saiths are winning because they have rigged the system, a system of corrupt politicians and bureaucrats. In a closed economy like Pakistan they win, they compound their wealth, they pretend to care for the people who work for them. They have learnt from their foreign counterparts very well, the only motive is profit at the cost of ambition.

Most of young graduates trade their ambition for job security and a fighting chance to get close to “management” some make it, most don’t and a vast majority die trying. The tiered system ensures, no one learns any thing new, companies don’t need innovation to win, they need legislation, lock-ins, essentially a machinery of inside men.

When you are not playing at the global scale, all you are doing is re aligning the chips to win locally. When you give up global competitiveness you only optimize for local pettiness, in doing so you ensure the learning outcomes of every one are stunted. When you don’t have to compete but rather co-opt your ambition also gives up.

Saiths and sponsors who build and list companies also manipulate their stocks. Every one knows it. We can also name the 4-5 brokers who do this, have been doing it for years, yet we don’t, my post is equally critical of all but the reason for writing is to make the youth aware of the principal/sponsor problem, for them to recognize they are being dealt a short hand. For them to have the fortitude to focus on their growth vs growing into roles that have no meaningful impact on their lives.

Another contributing factor is the stagnant growth of many local corporations. This lack of growth is due to a number of reasons, including poor management(as the saith aren’t some great operators, most are petty crooks in pretty suits), a lack of investment in innovation and research, and a lack of focus on expanding the business. When they make enough money their second generation comes in from Harvard and Yale with bright ideas, who are handed over to family advisors to be brainwashed in to “Abba jis” ways. Therein begins the second wave of more of the same. If kids don’t comply, Abba ji identifies some hired executive “munh bholay bataays” who are more than happy to carry out his wishes.

This can make it difficult for young professionals to find opportunities for advancement and can result in them feeling stuck in their careers, unable to grow and develop their skills when they look outside of Pakistan.

So what can be done?

In order to tackle the ambition tax and create a more inclusive and dynamic corporate culture, it is important to focus on implementing transparency in hiring and promotion processes, investing in growth and innovation, and encouraging the development of professional networks and mentorship programs.

By creating opportunities for young professionals to grow and develop their skills, we can help to create a more dynamic and competitive corporate culture in Pakistan, one that encourages ambition and hard work and not short-term-ism.

Additionally, it is important to support businesses that are run like real businesses, and to encourage a shift away from the traditional preference for family-owned businesses. This can be done by providing incentives for companies that invest in growth and development, and by highlighting the importance of professional management practices.

I have seriously high hopes with the newer generation to take a stand and do whats right, report your crooked bosses to your foreign owners, call a spade a spade, you owe it to your self and to Pakistan to not let this brazen miscarriage of negative outcomes shape your future. You owe none of these people any thing, you do not need to be subservient to any one.

This lack of initiative and innovation can be traced back to the fear of failure and the need to maintain job security in the face of economic uncertainty. This results in a culture where people play it safe and do not take risks, opting instead to be loyal to the owner even when it means making bad or wrong decisions. You owe it to your self to not do this any more.

How this re-wires the brains of the young grads and Why thats a bad thing…

From the perspective of young professionals who remain in safe roles for several years, the major disadvantage is that they miss out on opportunities to learn and grow, both professionally and personally. This can limit their career advancement and lead to a feeling of stagnation and frustration, as they are unable to fulfill their aspirations and reach their full potential.

Compared to their peers globally, young professionals who stay in safe roles for extended periods of time may miss out on opportunities to develop new skills, work on cutting-edge projects, and take on new challenges. This can make them less competitive in the global job market and hinder their ability to advance in their careers. Additionally, working in a stagnant environment with limited opportunities for growth can lead to boredom and disinterest, making it difficult for these individuals to remain engaged and motivated in their work and in their lives, leading to seriously un happy outcomes at home.

How does this Ambition tax destroy the country?

The high level of dissatisfaction among young professionals in Pakistan, where nearly half the population is under the age of 25, is a major concern for the country’s economic growth.

A lack of opportunities for professional development and growth, combined with the fear of failure and the need to maintain job security, can lead to a feeling of boredom and un fulfillment among young professionals. Leading to mass un productivity.

A non productive workforce that has nothing new to contribute, has significant economic consequences, as it increases the cost of hiring and training new employees, and reduces the productivity of businesses. Additionally, when talented young professionals leave the country in search of better opportunities, they take with them their skills, knowledge, and experience, reducing the pool of available talent and limiting the potential for economic growth.

The current economic situation in Pakistan further exacerbates these challenges. The country is facing a number of economic challenges, including high inflation, a large trade deficit, and a growing fiscal deficit. This has led to a challenging business environment, with high levels of uncertainty and volatility.

Unless we take ownership of our own issues and come up with a plan to tackle them. We will continue to shape our outcomes like our past, “stagnant with a high chance of extreme lows”

If you are young and motivated do your self a favor and read the thread below, today. Hard work alone is not going to change your outcomes. You knowing history will help. You deciding to change it, has the potential to change your outcomes.

Stop lying to your self!!!

Our collective quality of life is shit.

A primer on understanding why the middle class is in a self Serving bias on "why we have it so good here"

It started like all good things with great intentions. Do hard work and you'll do OK. but….
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) July 20, 2022

Historical Context that I covered in my News letter

Made in Pakistan (Pre Nationalization Monopolies)

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (1928–1979) became President of Pakistan (1971–74) on 21 December 1971 after a disastrous end of 1971 war with India. The nationalization programme was implemented for the first time in the history of Pakistan and it was promulgated through three different stages.

I recently came across a fantastic publication. Private Industrial Investment in Pakistan: 1960-1970.

Cambridge Study Purchase Link

Why is this important? It sheds light in to how the economy was structured and who controlled the monopolies before Nationalization eroded economic capital of the country. It also shows some thing very critical, the growth rates of industry by sector.

Far more interesting is that I was able to see for the first time, the interplay between banks, their ownership, the insurance companies and the overall major monopoly families and their directorships across enterprises. It was an eye opener for me. So as you start to build your journey of better outcomes, be mindful of history, understand how made in Pakistan can be extremely successful and the pitfalls you must avoid.

Why share all this. It demonstrates that no-major hands have changed since the creation of the country, its tumultuous nationalization of industries and the present day. The outcomes have worsened for the youngest and brightest. If you still don’t believe that none of the firms, corporation and their sponsors are all in it to win it, at your expense, the chart below fascinated me when I saw it you should give it a read.

What is it?

The inter-connectivity between the groups visualized circa the 60s.

What now?

The first step is to identify there is a problem.

The second step is to figure out what areas are within your control.

The third is to invest your time an energy to not get into this rat race, but instead look for alternates or build alternates that allow you to excel.

Do not be mis-lead by the fake allure of these corporations because sooner rather than later, they will tax your ambition and you too will be a cog in their machinery. Invest in your self by not investing your time and effort to chase a dream that at best is locally competitive and at worse is globally irrelevant.

KE is the biggest Fin-tech/Any-Tech/Data-Tech/Social Network in the Country if they wanted to be….

Love it or hate it, cant live without KE. With all the market making news around KE, there is a lot to be said and done around the assets KE has. Besides the power or energy it distributes, it has data that it doesn’t distribute or use insofar as I can tell.

Let’s look at the bill. Beyond the usual business of having consumer demographic details, their CNIC, it also has past payment history and consumption info.

From KEs Bill Explainer

If we just take the basics. KE has the ability to be single largest fin-tech play in the country. If you asked me, I would have had them apply for a digital banking license bar none. Why?

Let’s deep dive into the theory looking at their standard bill.

What do they know about the connection owner?

Male/Female
Actual Bill Amount
Payment frequency
Usage consumption, up or down co-related to weather
Address
At least 10+ years of all this data is digitally available

What does one need to base lending decisions on typically at a fin-tech/bank/credit co? Most if not all of the above. But wait, it doesn’t end here. This is what is non extrapolated and non implied data.

Now let’s look at what else they could know or use?

They can group people into affluence/segments based on data from a neighborhood
They could club neighborhoods by pay-back rates + timeliness
They also have one super power no one else does or can, they know the channel where the payment was made
- Online
- Bank Branch
- Which Bank
- Cash
- Online Transfer
- Bill Aggregator
Based on this they can build heat maps on
- Cash based payment locations + banks + centers
- Time of day month etc when those payments are made
- Who are the folks that have delinquent payments
- Who are those that pay for payment plans
- Can you offer pre paid subscriptions and collect advance cash from Tier one customers?

What else could they monetize for them to be a 10x Valuation play?

Data, data and more (small data)
Make your constituents download your app or consent to giving them their home/commercial connection pin location(more on this later, if you are a KE board member email me and ask nicely)
Push notifications and discounts via app (more on this)
Incentivize users to go beyond the abysmal 500k Downloads today of the app
As an entity KE Serves 2.5M Adult customers(whose demographic/psychographic info is in the system some where but not being used)
KE’s distribution network spans across 6,500 km² based on their data, imagine the maps applicability that could be unleashed if they actually stored and curated this data

How can a small change in their data/digital strategy make them help consumers pay their bills ?

Once you drive up app installs make it the most useful app, by having video/news/games/content in it. At 1M daily active users and looking at our consumption habits you serve people with ads, if they have the ability to use part of the ad-revenue you make to pay off their bill, you would be the first electric utility company in the world to monetize a completely different channel..But wait theres more..
For the above example we are assuming you turn on some one else’s content and likely googles ad-network. But if it were up to me, you would build your own/reuse some one else’s tech to run your own ad-network. Why, because you have the single most populated cities 1st party user data. Meaning what you could charge for targeted ads, google would pay you to connect to your network. No one in Pakistan(sans the dumb telcos) have this data, who also by the way have no ad-network of their own.(Tried and failed twice, because their chief digital officers are ex marketing mavens, and bad at that too-Historically speaking)
But wait there is more, if you take NextDoors example from the US, the only company that has the slightest chance to build a local communal social network in Pakistan is KE leading to local commerce, payments and monetization of every transaction on that network, dont forget UGC news, health and other use cases.
What KE has is the ability to build a trust network. Granted they have shitty PR, but this is what it takes. Most of this costs under 1M$ to roll out a real working product.

As the corporate changes, ownership scuffles and PE battles enrage, the operating company should be focusing on building value.

If I was a shareholder, which I am not, I would ask, Is this company, with the above data plays, a better monetized asset? When/if the eventual sales happens to the Chinese, does the valuation go up?

Should the government that is 23% strategic share holder and on the board, demand that KE innovate because these seemingly small data plays can increase revenue + reduce the burden of power costs on the end consumer by really doing some thing out of the box.

It is the consumers data, with the state involved perhaps the state can nudge KE into enhancing their outcomes. Who doesn’t want, or need better outcomes. The people of Karachi could most certainly use them and a lower bill potentially. Or have avenues to make additional money by engaging in local commerce.

I wanted to go look up the BOD of KE, sadly their profiles aren’t hyper linked any more https://www.ke.com.pk/corporate/board-of-directors/ but still show up on a google search. Interestingly enough some of the folks whose profiles aren’t on the Bod Page. Perhaps new directors to come or old ones whose links still on Google. But I digress. I wanted to take a look to understand who in this lot would have the courage to ask the Management to do some thing bold. Don’t know the answer yet.

The fact of the matter is, a lot can be done, there is immense potential both to the current share holders, the market at large and any future buyer from a resultant asset sale. The question is, will they recognize what they have? Like most Pakistani asset flips, is this just vanilla for a quick upside? Or with the change of play in the BOD they will actually go ahead and bring some critical thinking besides rubber stamping of votes for an eventual sale. I mean just basing this on historical items and nothing besides that.

I have no horse in this race, besides being a consumer, who would like continuous un interrupted power supply and if by some miracle, these guys are able to do a further turn around on the back of a real digital transformation that allows me and other end user some relief from sky high rates, whilst adding to economic progress of the constituents they serve, I’d be all for it.

**Note to BOD, if you are thinking of or are already engaged with McKinsey or Bain, on the insistence of your management team, you are better off re reading what I shared for free and save your self the same BS they took to every bank, every navigation co, every telco, every food science company in the country. Its one standard deck with whitewashed commentary that sounds better coming from some one whose not of local disposition. Sharing this so you can conserve your FX at such a critical time in the country’s history.

Key initiatives to drive the digitization of the economy and unlocking Dollar Based inflows

We all want good things to happen to us, but not many are willing to go out on a limb to share the things our government and state actors must do. In an effort to start a healthy debate and put-forth some ideas, thinking and suggestions I decided to publish a cliff notes equivalent of what we need our government to do.

As always take the ideas & suggestions with a pinch of salt. Forgive the errors as it is late night thinking translated in to some discussion points that have been shared plenty of times with those who have asked in the past. Its is far from perfect/cohesive, but it’s a starting position. Some thing that enables, mature adult conversations.

Feel free to share your ideas and thoughts here or via the twitter post that led you to this post. All I ask for is a civil and mature discourse even if you disagree with the content.

#PakistanStrong

Digital-Transformation-Remedies Download

New Minister New 🧵 to Unlock the Tech $s we Need

"Initiatives the Government Should take to drive Digitization & Unlock Dollarized Inflows"

Here are some suggestions for our New Finance Minister to collectively help the Pakistani Tech Ecosystem do better & in turn Pakistan pic.twitter.com/S7bntFAIFU
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) September 26, 2022

A Simple Guide to Unlocking 300m$ in Foreign Exchange in 120 Days by Supporting Pakistans Technology Ecosystem.

Take the ideas and suggestions with a pinch of salt, also I am not great at public math. Forgive the errors as its a one persons late night thinking translated in to some discussion points. Its is far from perfect or even cohesive, but in my mind it’s a starting point. Instead of every one suggesting the problems we face, here is an attempt at offering some solutions or a path to solving what ails us.

Feel free to share your ideas and thoughts here or via the twitter post that led you to this post. All I ask for is a civil and mature discourse even if you disagree with the content.

#PakistanStrong

DigitalEconomyEnablement Download

"Unlocking about 300M$ in Foreign Exchange in 120 Days"🧵

Every Day Twitter Asks me "What's Happening"

Well a lot, only if we got our act together. Here are some suggestions for our New Government to collectively help the Pakistani Tech ecosystem do better & in turn Pakistan
— Faizan Siddiqi (@faizansiddiqi) April 15, 2022